2023 is the year that the fluorescent tube gets banned in Europe, and may be progressively banned in various American states.
I found this old sign illumination module and thought it would be worth making a video about it.
I could have had a rant about how many LED lights have had efficiency and lifespan specifications that are just utter lies, and how you can't even change a lamp in a modern fixture. But instead I'll just give the proven fluorescent technology the dignity it deserves.
The basics of the classic fluorescent tube is that it contains a carrier gas and tiny amount of mercury vapour. The mercury vapour gives off UV that stimulates the internal phosphor coating and converts it to white light. The ends of the tubes have heated cathodes with a thermo-emissive coating that lowers the voltage drop between the electrode and gas when it is heated. Initially it's heated by direct powering of the heaters, but is then maintained in a hot state by the normal tube operation.
Some ballast circuits have the power factor correction capacitor in series with the rest of the circuit.
If you enjoy these videos you can help support the channel with a dollar for coffee, cookies and random gadgets for disassembly at:- https://www.bigclive.com/coffee.htm
This also keeps the channel independent of YouTube's algorithm quirks, allowing it to be a bit more dangerous and naughty.
#ElectronicsCreators

While digging through my workshop, I came across an old fluorescent light module out of a same box and I Thought it'd be interesting taking taking a look at it because although it's not quite vintage yet, it's going to be vintage soon because these things have been replaced completely with the strings of LED modules. So this one has a very simple metal chassis with the inductor on it or chassis if you're American with the induction on it, the chalk as we'd call it here and it's got the fluorescent tube. and the fluorescent tube itself has the starter built into the end. and if I turn this on now, you'll see that it's the old-fashioned circuitry, no electronics.

Well, not much in the real. Electronics when I plug this in, it also blink a few times before it starts so it started quite quickly. But what actually happened in there initially? This little thing in the end: I'm going to turn that light off now because it's far too bright. Initially, what happened was this little starter.

in the end uh provided a current path through heaters to actually heat them up before it's struck and I can take this off just to show the construction. It's very simple. This is the lamp with the starter built in and this is just a simple inductor. It's got live neutral and Earth the neutral was uh, straight to the lamp.

the live goes through. then doctor comes back here, then Doctor and goes to the other end of the lamp and the Earth just goes onto the Chasse Okay, I'm going to zoom back out, but because I'm going to bring in the notepad and draw this down, there will be no surprises to those who are veterans of the electrical industry. I'm just going to team this down a watch me tame it down. just way too much.

Yeah, it's not bad, it's not bad. So ultimately you know this is just a standard fluorescent fitting but just combined into a small enclosure. So the tube itself looks like this. It's a continuous tube of glass and inside that is a carrier gas which is sometimes organ, sometimes Krypton And there's also in the end a little heating element.

The heating element is coated in a thermionic coating and what happens is that when you heat that up it starts emitting electrons and that basically lowers what they call the the cathode drop at the tube and it makes it easier to light the tube. If you were driving this as a knee in tuber, it would be called cathode. Literally just a one electrode to each end and choose Brute Force to get it to start. This makes things much easier.

It means you don't need a high voltage in engines for so the power supply for this the is say for instance here is the neutral and here is the live but via that inductor and the inductor is just used to limit the current through it. Some cheap out systems use a resistor, but the resistor is very wasteful because it dissipates always heat. The capacitors are not good for this because they only spin the tube, strengthen each half cycle, it causes a huge current pulse and quickly damages the Troopers Inductors are the ideal choice for this. and basically speaking as the currents flowing uh through the inductors pushing back against, it's just an efficient way of limiting current fairly efficiently.
Incidentally, if the this has been a perfect fixture, there would have been a capacitor across like that because that is a simple inductive circuit. Relatively simple inductive circuit. However, there was a pin. There are just terrible.

They're just like capacitors and fluorescent fittings are not my favorite thing. So these two other electrons, there's two connections. they come up to another little Globe that's that looking one there. very black and they always go like that.

And inside that globe and I'll just draw an exaggerated size. It's filled with a gas like neon. Define Tuna gas and the pressure to the voltage required and tacked onto one of those electrodes is a little bi-metallic strip like that. and then this little file thing doesn't.

It's not even marked for the volume. I Could measure that I Could measure that right now. one moment, please. It is measured 3.5 nanofarad.

It's purely for suppression because it's across the contacts in there, but we'll contribute to the blackening those contacts. So let's say 3.5 Nano Farad. This one down here would depend on the reaching of the fluorescent tube. I'm not really sure what it'd be, it would just be in sort of low microfires.

Like one or two microfires probably. But this is full of a neon gas and initially, when you power this circuit up, if the trooper hasn't struck the open circuit voltage across, that is the full means voltage, which is 240 volts. So you get in the case of the UK, you get 20040 volts across it and that causes the gas to Glow in this tube. and that quickly heats the bimetallic strip up until it physically touches the other electrode.

And when it does that, current flows directly through the inductor through each of these little heater filaments at the end, through that shunted starter, through the other heating filament, and they start heating up. And because it's shunted itself out, this unit will now cool down, and because it's cooling down, the bimetallic strip will break apart again. and uh, when it does that, the depending where it does it in the same way if it causes a high voltage spake and also because these are heated slightly, they may be a level that the voltage across them has dropped that it can actually ignite the tube. If it doesn't, the cycle starts again.

that just keeps going tap tap tap tap tap tap tap until it lays. If you've got a bad tube that's not lighting, you may find the starter. That's when you'll see it just going. Flash flash flash flash flash and not lighting.

The other thing you'll often see, particularly with tubes like this, is that just glowing orange at the end. If it's just basically glowing orange around the end here, and there's a good chance the starter has welded and something you can actually do for that is just to basically get the base and ping it like that. just give it a sharp tap and that sometimes gets a bit more life out then. But at that point in time, it's your warning that you're going to need a new tube.
Um, and that's more or less anything else worth seeing. I've got the thermionic emissive coating. Get the neon in here. Oh, that's the other thing.

Once it has struck, the voltage across this tube will typically drop to 90 volts. and at 90 volts, the gas is chosen to actually not sustain the conduction of that. But sometimes you might find tubes that actually do light up and then the starter kicks in again. they go out again, then it lights up.

and that is because the voltage across the tube, the electrode Ms of Coatings are basically sputtered off and that causes blackening at the end of the tubes. and uh, when that happens the voltage cross. This is enough to actually make it kick back in again. That starts it think thinks the lamp's not struck but in reality it was and it just keeps flashing and pulsing.

it Make sure you think that maybe the LEDs are a good option, but having said that, you've all seen those signs that are just basically the LED signs with the power supply that's failed and it's doing its flash flash flash. So which was worse? But there we go. These had a very long life. The troops there I mean they lasted an extremely long time, probably more than many of the LED replacements.

But now that the European red tape manufacturers are basically, well, this year I think is the last year they're allowed to manufacture for the national troops in Europe and not sure that's going to go with the germicidal ones, but there we have it. Um, there will be no choice but to go for LED And at some point this trip here is going to become a vintage artifact along with all its circuitry. They're strange how times have changed and what was radically new at the time is just now out of date.

15 thoughts on “Retro already?”
  1. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars nurseSean says:

    I like the efficiency of LED but I donโ€™t like the flickering (high speed while working and low speed when they fail) or the monochromatic light.

  2. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars insert generic name here says:

    We replaced them with LED as soon as they broke. Not going back.

  3. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars VHFGamer says:

    Can't say I'll miss florescent bulbs. The light quality sucked, they didn't last long, and they took forever to reach full brightness.

  4. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Altezza1999 says:

    I've had a finnish architect lamp for 16 years and it still works so well that I cant imagine throwing it out just cause it "uses too much power" and thus the tubes disappear from the stores.

  5. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Coconut219 says:

    Europe is going to be lit by candles by 2024 if you don't get rid of these clowns.

  6. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Snab Kassa says:

    I've never stayed in an hotel that has these where 1 or 2 didn't need replacing.

  7. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars zapa1pnt says:

    In the US, the "inductor", in a fluorescent fixture, is known as a ballast.

  8. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars CamperMike says:

    Yea ban a bulb there are thousands and thousands of fixtures out there using to you have to buy all new and trash the old fixtures creating more waste. And what with the led lights that you have to replace the entire fixture when they fail creating even more waste

  9. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars qwerty keyboard says:

    The LED lamps in our old fridge where long since dead when we moved in.

    Never once have I seen a dead inconsecent lamp in a fridge.

  10. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Kuntal Ghosh says:

    I use this type of "pl lamp" in my desk. I do not like the led color rendering. These are much easier on eyes for some reason.
    I think i should keep a pack of ten at home cus these seem to last forever in storage. The last one i used was in storage for 10 years and it ran for 6 years after that. The current one i am using was purchased last year. They are getting increasingly rare to find.
    I do not have a single led light at home. All are tubes with classic ballast and starer. They last forever. Over 2x 3x better than led. Leds do not even last as long as a incandescent.
    I had fitted osram led in my motorcycle and the light gave up after 2 years. I am back on halogen now. The longest i have seen them go is 5 years and generally they all fail in 1-2 years if you use them regularly like tube lights. While tube lights in my home generally last for 6years or more.
    The electricity savings aren't worth the hassle with these led.

  11. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars erg0centric says:

    *radically new

    I remember having a few replacement fluorescent starters from the dark ages before they were integrated onto the tube.

    We had some circlelights as well. The beginning of electronic ballasts.

  12. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Frank Wilson says:

    Uni where I worked switched the CFL hall and ceiling lights to LEDs three years ago… fast forward, most of the dome hall lights in my building all packed in. It appears that they had an IR proximity dimmer which piggybacked onto the LED control, and the dimmers all stopped working. The more complex circuit simply had more engineering bugs show up. The CFLs in other buildings which are the same vintage all still work 15+ years on.

  13. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Andy Dingley says:

    I've a 30 year old Ikea desklights with one of these in. Still one of my favourite lights. It's a big long lamp, so it doesn't give awkward shadows. It just works better than any LED lights I have.

  14. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Dave says:

    As an American, I say 'chassis' rather than 'chassis'.

  15. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Simon Hopkins says:

    It's past time we in the UK demand a right to repair act. I went to the recycling centre aka the skips recently. And was not surprised by the thousands of pounds in technology just discarded.
    I should be shocked but it's normal to discard K's ๐Ÿ˜ข

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.