These surge protectors were being sold as "returns" from a major online retailer at a suspicious price of £10 for four. I felt the urge to buy a set to check out.
It turns out they were perfect for sale on eBay since they have at least one major manufacturing defect that means they can't indicate when they have ceased to provide protection, and may possibly continue to pass current even when they are supposed to have triggered their thermal safety device.
eBay is full of this stuff because they have no easy way to report a listing for a dangerous product. However, they DO have ways to report items that will undermine their profit.
It's a shame the UK electrical industry is price gouging SPDs (Surge Protective/Protection Devices), as it encourages people to use rogue imports like these - which may well work, but will not always be made with proper quality control.
I have a UK compliant SPD on order for our exploration.
If you enjoy these videos you can help support the channel with a dollar for coffee, cookies and random gadgets for disassembly at:- https://www.bigclive.com/coffee.htm
This also keeps the channel independent of YouTube's algorithm quirks, allowing it to be a bit more dangerous and naughty.
#ElectronicsCreators

I've looked at surge protective devices in the past before and they were quite interesting. These are from eBay and they were actually described as returns item to a major online retailer I'm guessing maybe that was perhaps Amazon although I could be wrong, but uh, they've obviously been recalled from that retailer and then they've been dumped on eBay and it says make the quality more perfect in the box and they have not made the quality more perfect. So let me explain how these work. You clip the unit into a DIN rail onto the DIN rail in your electrical distribution equipment.

you put your live in here if you're in a country with more than one Uh phase, then you put each phase into a separate unit and then there is an earth connection or a ground connection here and an event of a huge high voltage electrical. Spike See a lightning strike or electrical interference, transients, inductive loads. This component inside will go from a high resistance state to a low resistance state that will just clip it and it will protect your electrical equipment. But in doing so over time these degrade and you know, if you're in a non-electrically noisy environment, if you're you're sort of.

you've got other suppression as well. It may be this will last forever effectively, but we've got a lot of electrical spikes occurring. It will gradually degrade each time until it starts gradually starts to conduct and it starts heating up. And that's a sort of end of life statement.

Here's what should happen when it heats up. Let me just bring in a picture to explain that. I Shall Focus down onto that for extra clarity. So here's the inside of the device and buried under this resin is the surge protecting device.

So one connection goes into one side and the other connection comes out is this tab with a low melting temperature, soldering and a little spring-loaded uh, pivot pulls down in this so that when that starts heating up, theoretically it will melt the soldering. When it does, it breaks the circuit down to the other end. and also this little flag goes down to show that it's tripped. However, there's also another little tab here that looks as though it's sized for a micro switch.

maybe in more specialist equipment or there is a whole fret here, but it would have to be a very small contact. But I think that's for possibly an auxiliary contact to remotely display that Uh Something's tripped inside. However, there is a problem with this. Let me show you what happens when this one trips.

I'll zoom in again and you can see that this one has the weed green window there. Let me just focus down that so you can see it's green. Which means that is good. It's operating.

However, when it trips, let me find something to trip it with. here. a pair of long nose pliers when it trips. I Shall just try and do that.

No, uh, lift this up and trip it so it's tripped down now. even though it's not peeled that connection out and instead of going red, it stayed green. And the reason for that is because this is a bad batch. This whole top window is supposed to be printed red, but they've actually just printed a red lane it.
So this could be in this situation and uh in its latch State it's displaying green but also in its unlatched state, it's also displaying green and it would indicate that you know it was good. When it's not, when it's actually the protection has been lost. I Tested one of these at work. Let me show you that video because I took a soldier and just touched this to see the mechanism operating properly.

Let's take a look at that video right now. Uh, it's left, it bridged again. it's left a slight Bridge of soda across that. so as you saw in that video it tripped but the little air Link at the top it seemed to drag a little whisker of the solder down with it which would have kept the circuit going I'm not sure what have happened if that got hotter and hotter.

maybe it would have eventually broken circuit. Not sure but um that also happened the last time I Tested one when I bought one as a as a new item that did of the proper flag. So it makes you realize that you know a lot of stuff that is being sold online from uh certain stores may actually be dangerously non-compliant of being dumped on the internet as happens. But there we go.

I Do recommend that if you ever install a surge protective device that because these can fail potentially in Flames I do kind of recommend that you mount in a separate metal enclosure and preferably with over current protection. I Do see items being sold by compliant sellers that claim not to need a circuit breaker in series I'm not totally convinced about that. Um, but there we have it. the surge protected devices from the Dumpster of the World eBay An excellent result.


12 thoughts on “Defective surge protector being dumped on ebay”
  1. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars ohio player1177 says:

    I wonder if you could ever do replacement screens for phones. I’m using one now that said it was an OLED screen and I can tell you that it doesn’t seem to be at all. The blacks are nice but not oled nice. It will be interesting to see the battery life and if it goes down as much as it think it will.

  2. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Friendly Nerd says:

    I thought it was power rangers SPD

  3. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Matheus Moreira says:

    "Make the quality more perfect"

  4. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars TANGLDWEB says:

    Na na na.
    Its just another bad Chinese English translation.
    It's "RE BURN" Item. The last customers are still in intensive care. So they won't be needing them 😂
    … always fun, …to watch from a distance 🖖

  5. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars PaulG says:

    To be honest , "more perfect" is open to interpretation.
    How can you disparage the manufacturer when you don't know how less perfect their quality was previously?

  6. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Dan says:

    Thats why i use phoneix contact devices

  7. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars thomas burns says:

    I would assume in a lightning strike the solder would completely break away due to the whole component being hot rather than just that iron

  8. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars skungpid says:

    Big Clive……you have to work on your pronunciation. You need to ESSSPLAIN the issue.

  9. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Worf says:

    Funny, in North America, these SPDs come in two types – Type 1 and Type 2. Type 1 is where the overcurrent protection to the SPD is built into it (so it has a lever to reset it like a normal breaker) and a Type 2 device which requires it to be placed after the overcurrent device. It's generally for where the SPD was to be installed – type 1 was for right after the meter, while type 2 is in the load center, but most manufacturers make both to plug into the load center these days. (Type 3 are for power bar SPDs, and Type 4 are in-device SPDs). The new load centers because of arc fault requirements often have "Plug On Neutral" connections where the neutral bus bar is also brought to the breaker instead of a pigtail, so the type 1 SPDs are used there (they plug in like a normal breaker across the phases). Type 2 usually are for retrofit situations where you add it to your load center in which case you wire up another set of breakers to the SPD.

  10. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars kyme32 says:

    One rule that i always follow, anything that follows after the grid separator need to have OCP

  11. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Aco747lyte says:

    Very useful to know, dear Clive. By your detailed videos and easy-to-understand explanations, you have saved my family and I a heck of a lot of trouble regarding electrical safety. ❤

  12. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Anthony Chopra says:

    Amazon becoming AliExspress more every day hahah

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.